top of page

7 Reasons Why Invisible Fences for Dogs Don’t Work

An invisible fence for dogs might sound like an ideal solution for allowing your dog to roam freely while keeping them safe within your yard. However, these systems can present several challenges and drawbacks that pet owners should consider.

How Does an Invisible Fence Work?

Invisible fencing systems use radio frequencies emitted by a cable buried underground, paired with a control panel or transmitter. The dog wears a receiver collar with prongs that deliver a warning tone and an electrical shock if the dog approaches or crosses the boundary. The shock is intended to be painful enough to deter the dog from leaving the yard.

1. Invisible Fences for DogsPotential Injury to the Dog

The shock from an invisible fence can be painful, and the collar itself can cause physical injuries. The prongs may rub against the dog's neck, leading to open wounds and infections. In severe cases, the collar can malfunction, delivering constant shocks and causing electrical burns.

2. Generalized Fear Behaviors in the Yard

The aversive training associated with invisible fences can make dogs fearful of being in the yard. Some dogs might avoid the yard altogether, while others might be reluctant to exit or enter the property, reducing their quality of life and enjoyment.

3. Invisible Fences for Dogs Equipment Failure

Invisible fence systems rely on batteries that eventually die. If the collar’s battery is dead and the pet owner doesn’t notice, the dog can walk through the boundary without receiving a shock. Some dogs even learn to drain the battery by triggering the warning tone repeatedly.

4. A Dog’s Prey Drive Might Be Greater Than the Shock

High-drive dogs might push through the pain of the shock if they see something irresistible, like a cat or a cyclist. This can lead to dogs escaping the yard despite the invisible fence.

5. Development of Inappropriate Behaviors

Dogs left alone in the yard for extended periods can develop problematic behaviors such as territory reactivity. Without a physical barrier, dogs have an unobstructed view of the outside world, which can trigger excessive barking and lunging at passersby, reinforcing negative behaviors.

6. Dogs Aren’t Protected From Threats Coming In

While an invisible fence may keep your dog inside the yard, it doesn’t prevent other animals, people, or wildlife from entering. This vulnerability can lead to dangerous encounters and injuries.

7. The Warning Tone Can Trigger “Beep Anxiety” Invisible Fences for Dogs

Some dogs may associate the warning tone and shock with any electronic beep, causing anxiety whenever they hear similar sounds, such as from household appliances or electronic devices.

Invisible Fencing Alternatives

Solid Fences

A solid fence is the best option for keeping dogs safe in a yard. Although it can be expensive and restricted in some neighborhoods, it provides a physical barrier that prevents escape and protects against outside threats.

Long Lines

Using a long line, a leash longer than typical walking leashes, allows your dog to explore the yard while giving you control. Long lines, ranging from 10-50 feet, let dogs enjoy the outdoors without the risks associated with invisible fences.

Supervised Yard Time

Joining your dog in the yard is the safest way to ensure their well-being. This allows for close supervision and the opportunity to bond and play together.

While invisible fences may seem convenient, they often come with significant risks and drawbacks. Consider these factors and explore safer alternatives to ensure your dog’s safety and happiness.

For more information on pet care and training, visit

Invisible fence for dogs
Invisible fence for dogs


Search By Tags
Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square
bottom of page